Thermoforming vs Fiberglass

We have gotten the question, "thermoforming vs fiberglass, which one is better?" Thermoforming and fiberglass are similar processes. Both have low startup costs compared to other methods, allowing cost-effective creation of lower quantities of parts. However, they also have some definite advantages and disadvantages. The charts below will help you understand the differences.

thermoforming process, Vacuum Forming
 

Thermoforming

Fiberglass

Fiberglass

A plastic production process that heats a rigid 2D sheet and uses a vacuum and pressure to form the plastic sheet (various materials) against a mold into a 3D shape.

Process in which fiberglass reinforced resin plastics are formed into 3D shapes. The process usually involves making a mold and then using the mold to make the fiberglass component.

Volume

Production volumes from hundreds to mid thousands. Thermoforming is the most cost-effective method out there.

Fiberglass is typically used for smaller runs and prototyping.

Material

HDPE or HMWPE (Polyethylene) is a popular material choice for replacing fiberglass. HDPE or HMWPE (Polyethylene) is more durable, crack and UV resistant and significantly lighter when compared to its fiberglass counterpart.

Global Thermoforming offers a variety of material options in colors, textures, thickness and specialty features like chemical resistance, flammability ratings and many more.

There are limited choices when it comes to Fiberglass material. The options are typically limited to fiber materials, fiber weave and either polyester or epoxy composite materials.

Finished Part Weight (See Specific Gravity Graph)

35% Lighter than Fiberglass

35% Heavier than Thermoformed parts

Finishing Options

Molded with color and texture options.

High-quality finishes without secondary operations such as painting needed.

Ability to paint, add finishes and screen print onto the finished part.

Ability to create high-gloss scratch-resistant finishes.

Metallic options are also available.

The finished part needs to be painted.

Minimal options for high-gloss, scratch-resistant finishes.

Recyclability

Final thermoformed parts and the excess material produced after CNC Trimming are fully recyclable.

Final parts are non-recyclable, and the Fiberglass production process uses a large amount of hazardous materials.

Labor Costs and Lead Times

Thermoforming is an automated process. Most parts are formed from an aluminum tool, helping to decrease lead times and keep labor costs low. Thermoforming is faster and less expensive in high volumes compared to fiberglass processes.

Fiberglass molding is a labor-intensive process and more often than not requires multiple tools for the production of a single part. The result is slower production output, higher costs and longer lead times compared to thermoforming operations.

Tolerances & Complex Geometry

Thermoforming can support the tight tolerances and complex geometries needed when creating mating parts.

Fiberglass processes are not as flexible when it comes to supporting complex geometries and tight tolerances needed to create mating parts.

Part-to-part Repeatability

5 Star Blue2 Star Yellow

Impact Resistance

5 Star Blue2 Star Yellow

UV Resistance

5 Star Blue3 Star Yellow

Molded-in Features

5 Star Blue2 Star Yellow

Durability

5 Star Blue3 Star Yellow

Specific Gravity of Thermoforming vs Fiberglass Materials

We use the specific gravity of a material to compare the weight of different materials. The lower the specific gravity of material the lower weight for an equal amount of material.

Comparing the specific gravity of conventional thermoplastics used in the thermoforming process against the specific gravities of routine fiberglass materials used in the fiberglass processes we can see that when wondering thermoforming vs fiberglass, thermoforming materials hold a distinct advantage.

Specific Gravity Chart, Thermoforming
Global Thermoforming White Logo

Have an upcoming project?

Whatever your manufacturing needs may be, Global Thermoforming can put our engineering, design, and manufacturing expertise to work for you.

Related Posts

MAAC Thermoforming machine

How Do Thermoforming Machines Work?

How does a thermoforming machine work? Each of the machines in our manufacturing facilities works by heating thin plastic sheets and stretching them over a mold to create precise shapes. However, each approaches their task differently. Let’s see how each play their role in our manufacturing process!

Read More »

Which Plastic Materials Are Used In Thermoforming?

Thermoforming plastic sheets can use many types of material – but there are some key characteristics to consider. Factors like transparency, hardness, rigidity or flexibility, and impact strength help manufacturers select the right thermoplastic for each part. At Global Thermoforming, we work with a variety to ensure the products you receive are made from the best material match for your needs!

Read More »

Share this posT

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email